"; ?> Curt's Online Journal: To refrigerate or not to refrigerate...

Curt's Online Journal
Wherever you go...there you are.

July 22, 2002

To refrigerate or not to refrigerate...

That is the question!

I pose this to everyone. Several of my companions and I have had discussions on whether or not it is necessary to store ketchup in the refrigerator. Some people say it should be stored in the refrigerator while other say it can be stored in the cupboard.

So, what is your take and why? Add your vote/comment and let's see where everyone falls. Besides, it will let you know who's ketchup to use and who's not to use. :)

Posted by Curt at July 22, 2002 12:55 PM

Comments

Ketchup tastes nicer cold and it cools down boiling hot food :D

Posted by: Mee at November 26, 2003 06:23 AM

Ketchup goes in the fridge... My mummy likes it cold...

Posted by: Hesky at November 24, 2003 03:02 PM

long live the cupboard ketchup i say

Posted by: fred at November 24, 2003 03:01 PM

I say "refrigerate", why take unecessary chances. (If you wanna be a rebel, ketchup isn't the most exciting venue.)My question is, what about pancake syrup? (grin)

Posted by: Veronica at October 15, 2003 01:26 PM

I THINK IF NOT REFRIGERATING KETCHUP WERE THAT DANGEROUS THAT WE WOULD ALL BE VERY SICK BECAUSE EVERY RESTAURANT I KNOW OF STORES THEIRS ON A SHELF AND WE ALL EAT IT WHEN WE GO OUT!

Posted by: GAYLE YOUNG at September 11, 2003 12:17 AM

check out most restaurants.. they DO NOT refrigerate ketchtup, it stays on the tables or on under a counter in the glass bottles and is not refrigerated... or even like mcdonalds - its in big pump containers and is not cold.. now granted, they go thru more ketchup regularily than the avg househould.. but still - restaurants don't refrig.. why should we?

Posted by: rachel at May 11, 2003 04:14 PM

I agree with Christina: "Cold ketchup certainly tastes better on a hot hamburger or hot dog."

However, if your putting cold ketchup onto a "hot hamburger", it seems proper to put cold ketchup onto hot "hot dog"; not simply hot dog. :)

Posted by: Aaron at March 31, 2003 12:51 AM

I guess when I posted this last week I obviously did not hit something right.. here goes again.

I agree with the majority, refrigeration seems to keep ketchup's flavor at it's fullest.

However, I have kept a ketchup bottle in my drawer at work for several months, and as long as you shake the bottle real well it seems to be allright.

Now, for those of us who either do not like ketchup or prefer other condiments ..
What about mustard??

Posted by: Amelia at August 1, 2002 08:00 PM

Cool!

Refrigeration wins. Even though it’s technically not necessary due to ketchup's acidic nature, it is the most prudent choice for those who desire long life :>)

Do we want to take a vote on whether or not ketchup is a valid condiment for potato chips?

I prefer dean's French onion dip but have been guilty of using ketchup when there is nothing else available. In my defense this is for 'regular' chips and not 'ruffles' or other varieties. Also those wacky Canadians actually sell a ketchup-flavored dip eh.

Craig

Posted by: Craig at July 28, 2002 11:12 PM

Since there is an overwhelming response from one side, I'll play devil's advocate. For those nay-sayer's out there, my ketchup is in the refrigerator (although my parents' ketchup is not).

I see some excellent points have been raised. As the devil's advocate for this particular discussion, I offer the following arguments:

1. Heinz says,

"Because it is a very acidic product, ketchup does not spoil easily. Once opened, in order to maintain the product's quality more effectively, we do suggest that ketchup (and any other processed food) be refrigerated after opening because refrigeration retards spoilage."

Points to note:
A) "...ketchup does not spoil easily."
B) "...we do suggest that ketchup...be refrigerated..." (note the word suggest, not require or are not responsible if you don't)

2. From the web site that Craig suggests, (http://sneakykitchen.com/Ideas/ketchup.htm)

"Ketchup should be stored in the refrigerator after opening. Kept chilled, it should be all right for up to six months. Ketchup keeps better than most foods, partly because of its acidity, but it isn't sufficiently acid to kill bacteria, mold and other microorganisms that may get into the bottle after opening. Refrigeration doesn't kill the 'bugs' either, but does slow their growth. She also recommends keeping the lid and mouth of the bottle clean."

Points to note:
A) "Ketchup should be stored in the refrigerator..." (again, should is used instead of strongly advise, dangerous not to, etc.)
B) "Kept chilled, it should be all right for up to six months" (and not chilled, how long...one week, one month, six months?)
C) "Refrigeration doesn't kill the 'bugs' either, but does slow their growth." (Well, isn't that comforting...only 500 bacteria instead of 10,000)

3. Ketchup bottles do NOT have refrigerate or refrigerate after opening.

4. Finally, let's look to our friends at the food and drug administration. This page (http://www.cfsan.fda.gov/~lrd/fr970224.html) talks about labeling of foods needing refrigeration. A couple items to note:


"Foods such as mustard, salad dressings, jams, jellies, salsa, and spaghetti sauce bear a statement advising refrigeration once the product is opened to retard deterioration in the quality of the food. Nonetheless, consumers often do not refrigerate these foods. Although consumers may notice a deterioration in flavor, color, or texture over time, they may not associate foodborne illness with consumption of these products. Therefore, consumers do not seem to associate safety concerns with the keep refrigerated or refrigerate after opening statements."

and...


"The suggested optional label statement for Group C foods is: Refrigerate for Quality or some other statement that explains to the consumer that the storage conditions are recommended to protect the quality of the product."

Points to note:
A) Ketchup is not included in the list of products people commonly do not refrigerate but should, and apparently there are a a fair amount people who leave it out of the refrigerator.
B) The article goes on to mention guidelines for labeling and kethcup falls in group C meaning only the quality may decline by not refrigerating.


So, where does this leave us? Easy, Mike says to refrigerate. :)

Posted by: Curt at July 23, 2002 04:39 PM

Refridgerated: That's the way I grew up, an that's the way its' gonna be.

Posted by: Mike at July 22, 2002 06:19 PM

Once open it must be refrigerated. Boban beat me to the Heinz Link so i'll post another one.Its at the end of the page but it also recommend refrigeration for pretty much the same reasons.
http://sneakykitchen.com/Ideas/ketchup.htm

and for the strange people who must use the argument of putting cold ketchup on warm food here is another debate on the subject
http://www.geocities.com/SoHo/Cafe/5536/july30.html

now green ketchup is a different story since you can't tell even if it does spoil!

Posted by: Craig at July 22, 2002 06:17 PM

My personal opinion is that ketchup should be refrigerated after opening. Apparently Heinz agrees because "refrigeration retards spoilage."

http://www.heinz.com/jsp/consumer_faq.jsp#16

Posted by: Boban at July 22, 2002 05:21 PM

Ketchup is gross. I wouldn't put it on anything except for squirting it on someone's white shirt who you dislike. Hot or Cold-doesn't matter as long as the stain stays for a long time.

Posted by: Tom at July 22, 2002 03:25 PM

I think that ketchup should be refrigerated. Cold ketchup certainly tastes better on a hot hamburger or hot dog.

Posted by: Christina at July 22, 2002 02:42 PM

Refrigerating ketchup keeps the flavor at its peak. However, un-refrigerated ketchup is safe to eat, after several weeks the air will dilute the ketchup’s flavor (and of course if this happens then it won’t mask the flavor of whatever it is you don’t want to taste!)

So I say Refrigerate!

Posted by: Molly Jean at July 22, 2002 01:38 PM

Fatal error: Uncaught Error: Call to undefined function dispTools() in /home/cgomulin/public_html/curt/log/archives/000021.php:324 Stack trace: #0 {main} thrown in /home/cgomulin/public_html/curt/log/archives/000021.php on line 324